logoalt Hacker News

num42today at 3:34 PM3 repliesview on HN

Long live Anna’s Archive. I stand on the shoulders of the Internet, Wikipedia, Anna’s Archive, Z-Library, LibGen, YouTube, Hacker News, Reddit, and Sci-Hub.

I deeply admire the people who are obsessed with their passions and strive to build things that will lay the foundations for others.


Replies

sam_lowry_today at 3:44 PM

Why don't Google, OpenAI, Anthropic, Facebook & Co defend Anna's Archive publicly?

Coming out would be a bold move for them.

show 4 replies
xtractotoday at 4:45 PM

You missed Gigapedia (library.nu [1]) , which preceded most of the others.

Although I partially applaud what Anna's Archive is doing, I like their model the least (they want to CHARGE to download while doing Copyright infringement?).

In any case, I strongly believe that Anna's Archive is the wrong approach, as it has a single point of failure. We have been doing massive P2P sharing for more than 26 years; we have the algorithms for fully distributed file sharing and databases. Why are we still depending on HTTP/DNS based interfaces that are easily taken down by people wanting to limit knowledge?

I'm glad and thankful that the people behind Anna's Archive dedicate their time maintaining the huge base of human knowledge (Encyclopedia Galactica Asimov would say), but we (the people) should make it really distributed, really infallible and accessible (no, downloading 10TB torrent files doesn't make sense, except for archiving purposes).

We should have something like Popcorn Time but for knowledge.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library.nu

show 3 replies
mips_avatartoday at 5:55 PM

I wouldn’t include YouTube given how only Google is allowed to index it