logoalt Hacker News

mfondatoday at 4:26 PM1 replyview on HN

I have—frequently—especially among the non-technical crowd.

For example, the recent-ish OpenAI Hugging Face breakout was widely reported as a rogue model escaping. But a model on its own can’t do anything—it’s the agent/harness that escaped. I think it’s an important distinction and I’m glad to see efforts attempting to clear it up.


Replies

llm_nerdtoday at 4:29 PM

>But a model on its own can’t do anything—it’s the agent/harness that escaped

An agent/harness "can't do anything" on its own either, so how is saying "an agent escaped" somehow accurate? People talked about the model because it was the model that made the difference. It was specifically the differentiating factor. Not to mention that then you get into the weeds of meaningless arguments like "well actually the agent didn't, TCP packets did"..."well actually it was electrons and photons"...

I knew this would turn into a super boring thing where people will announce that they too misunderstood, therefore everyone does, but this is all very silly nonsense.

show 1 reply