logoalt Hacker News

estearumtoday at 10:22 AM1 replyview on HN

You hypothesize it's an important distinction. For now, what we have evidence for is the correlations of those things bundled together.


Replies

ninkendotoday at 10:59 AM

Because that’s all we seem to have measured. So, hypothesizing about whether there’s any other finer-grained causation in the data is the logical next step.

Me personally, I have immense trouble believing that passively watching entertainment has the same effect on working memory as, say, playing video games. And even within video games there’s probably a distinction between the more story-driven games that are a lot more passive to play, versus puzzle games that require active reasoning, versus games that test reaction time or memorization, etc.

(Full disclosure: I was a child of the 80’s and raised by a Nintendo and my computer. I think I turned out ok but I don’t have any alternative childhood to compare to)

show 3 replies