logoalt Hacker News

jubilantiyesterday at 8:47 PM5 repliesview on HN

Futurism is a focus on the future. The future may be good or bad. Your desire to focus only on the upsides (for you) and not want to hear about the consequences, externalities, or dangers is one of the most "political" positions a technologist can have.

Do you hate reading most science fiction? Because the ratio of dystopic to utopic scifi is pretty unbalanced.


Replies

modelessyesterday at 9:34 PM

Yeah, I hate modern science fiction. It's almost all terrible. Sci-fi written in the time of actual ongoing world wars and the Cold War's constant threat of instant nuclear annihilation was far more optimistic, and far more imaginative.

show 2 replies
m463today at 2:03 AM

I've wondered about that.

Recently I have read fiction where someone discovers a spaceship/artifact/portal/alien/mcguffin/etc and then they... get the mcguffin, get more stuff, get the girl, win. The plot is just a straight line.

they're boring.

Although not a straight line, any superhero movie. they're predictable and therefore, boring.

So I found the stuff that used to fill me with wonder, I shy away from. I don't want to watch another marvel hero.

I kind of wonder if non-utopia scifi, with reality and struggles and character development... is that the good stuff? doesn't have to all be dark forest or enshittification++ though.

I liked district 9 for instance.

ralfdyesterday at 9:26 PM

That is a modern phenomena though. Classic scifi was optimistic and utopian. But today even Star Trek has to be bleak/gritty/depressing.

show 3 replies
kulahanyesterday at 9:20 PM

You could just say “no” - it would save a lot of space, be about as polite, and way less annoying.

Sometimes people want to talk about science stuff without talking about human fallout and political implications. It’s perfectly fine to want an occasional break from those types of discussions.

show 1 reply