logoalt Hacker News

SoftTalkertoday at 6:22 PM5 repliesview on HN

For the recent cyclospora outbreak, a relatively tiny number of people were affected. Per the CDC[1]: 17,180 cases; 922 Hospitalizations; 2 deaths.

Not to diminish this for anyone affected, but the safety of driving cars is far worse than that and most of us do that daily.

I never stopped buying or eating lettuce.

[1] https://www.cdc.gov/cyclosporiasis/cases/index.html


Replies

timschmidttoday at 6:46 PM

I was one of those affected. The official CDC numbers are underestimates, because they're only counting cases confirmed by culture. My doc asked enough questions to make sure it wasn't your typical stomach flu or food poisoning and got me the antibiotics ASAP which I appreciated. I assume I'm not counted as a result. I have to assume others aren't as well.

show 1 reply
nkrisctoday at 7:20 PM

Comparing it to car safety does put it in perspective, but at the same time the safety of cars has nothing to do with food safety. Considering the necessity of food for life, and the fact our current population size is dependent on industrialized farming, I think it's worth to scrutinize food safety and hold it to a high standard.

lazystartoday at 7:15 PM

> but the safety of driving cars is far worse than that and most of us do that daily.

this "whattabout"ism is brought up during every safety discussion. can we please accept that 1/ everyone knows about the car issue, and 2/ the car issue being a problem does not mean we should stop talking about other issues that exist.

show 1 reply
GuinansEyebrowstoday at 8:15 PM

i have health insurance, i know i got it, and i rode it out without going to the doctor (not saying that was the right choice, it's just what i did).

i guarantee you that first number is wildly non-illustrative of the reach of this outbreak.

ansleytoday at 6:30 PM

"not to diminish" as you wave away 2 people that have died and make a false equivalency to traffic accidents.

This is not a data exercise, this is real life and 1 person getting sick from this stuff is too much.

show 1 reply