logoalt Hacker News

Labo333today at 3:46 PM2 repliesview on HN

I'm not even sure a PhD helps. It just overuses jargon that has NO meaning. Sometimes, it actually hand waves too much as well while trying to dumb down stuff for you.

I am not sure whether it's a consequence of learning to reason from its traces or some RLHF that trips it into using weird terms to sound smarter to the humans who rate it.


Replies

fnytoday at 4:19 PM

PhD was a joke.

My intuition is that Claude is trained to communicate to itself while coding. You see this in how bizarrely granular it is when explanation prior work, you also see this in the comments it leaves behinds.

show 1 reply
black_knighttoday at 4:03 PM

I have a PhD and can confirm. Oftentimes, the stuff which comes out of Claude is just impenetrable because it invents jargon on the fly, and uses verbs in the most atrocious ways.

"The fibred side folded its capstone into the existing name, so the kinds are asymmetric."

What on earth does it mean to fold a capstone into a name‽

show 1 reply