logoalt Hacker News

mapontoseventhstoday at 1:59 PM7 repliesview on HN

If your app is just a webpage that forces me to use an app just so you can spy on me I just won't use your product. I've switched brokers over it, I swapped banks, I stopped shopping at certain stores.

I'm done. The only say I have is in how I spend my money. Those companies won't get any of mine if I can help it.

I am the customer, not the product dammit.


Replies

srousseytoday at 3:01 PM

Twitter is the worst. You go to a page and scroll down and it banners a beater in the app thing and you can’t dismiss it. You either get the app or close the tab. Close the tab.

show 6 replies
aljgztoday at 2:54 PM

> The only say I have is in how I spend my money.

This. I get Frame.work and install Fedora. Use Firefox for everything possible. Once my current phone dies, I'll get a Fair phone, Motorola, or whatever gives me control.

Can't complain if I keep choosing hostile products for some convenience

show 1 reply
m463today at 3:29 PM

Can't buy a tesla without the app.

Worse, to sell a tesla, you are the person saying "ok, install the app, then I can transfer ownership to you, conveniently!"

and this is getting normalized with other car manufacturers.

(and it ALL goes back to apple... who started the whole app nonsense, and promoted a look-and-feel that gave tesla a terrible tap and swipe iphone/ipad type ui in a moving car)

show 3 replies
ethersteedstoday at 2:05 PM

Who are the hall of shame brokers?

IndySuntoday at 4:58 PM

Well said. Are there any mainstream apps "website as app" that do not come with the spying/telemetry/doxing (given on a plate by our two choices, ios/android) that almost always comes with them?

cavoiromtoday at 4:16 PM

I agree with you. But some time the social aspect in our life force us to to make compromise.

jader201today at 3:29 PM

> I am the customer, not the product dammit.

That’s an illusion that died a long time ago, unfortunately.

Just because you’re using their service on a browser doesn’t stop them from harvesting data from your usage, especially if you’re logging in (and if you’re using their services, chances are that you are).

Using browser over app can help, but it doesn’t eliminate it.

Like it or not, we’re the product, and I don’t see that changing anytime soon.

show 2 replies