logoalt Hacker News

LeoPantheratoday at 2:33 PM4 repliesview on HN

Do we know that Windows 11 has suffered due to the use of genAI or is that just a random snipe?


Replies

tehbeardtoday at 2:40 PM

It's based off that 30% of code written by AI quote from the MS CEO last year.

https://www.cnbc.com/2025/04/29/satya-nadella-says-as-much-a...

Note that he said written by, not assisted; and also that there's been some major QA issues with win11 the last year, enough for Microsoft to have made a public apology/commitment to improve...

So, no definitive evidence, but the rest of the breadcrumbs provide enough to say that yes it does appear to have suffered from it.

Given the Debian policy seems more geared towards aided/assisted an existing dev than replacing them and shipping because the code works on the golden path on a devs monster pc ... Well I'd still keep an eye on it but trust OSS OS engineers to have some competence at knowing if this works and adjusting the policy later if it proved to be wrong.

yoyohello13today at 3:43 PM

They’ve broken their own record of massive breaking updates in the last year.

LoganDarktoday at 2:35 PM

Either they're using GenAI or the entire team collectively lost their minds and started getting a huge number of colossally bad ideas about fundamental primitives of Windows that hadn't changed for decades. Backwards compatibility used to be the major concern and now it feels like they didn't even know what would break ahead of time. If that doesn't feel like GenAI then I don't know what does

show 2 replies
loloquwowndueotoday at 2:35 PM

lol windows doesn’t need AI to be the dumpster fire it’s always been