alt Hacker NewsI've seen people claim that using Claude Code makes you racist.
Replies
What's interesting is that they are trying to make a larger political point, but after boiling away all the nuance into such an aggressive and misguided statement, it makes me not want to engage at all.
Is there a term for this? Ensnarkification? I see it on X and bsky all the time.
It used to be the case that you would see someone posting under an avatar like that and you would dismiss their argument right away without even reading it.
Apparently LLMs are fascist technology according to one (now former) Debian developer and using it is supporting fascism.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HQ5MeeaXUAAIMLX?format=jpg&name=...
Somewhat insulting to those that actually lived (or live) under fascism.
I don't know if they truly believe that persons using CC are racist (like they examined the thing logically from bottom to top and came back with that conclusion) or if it's the new Goodwin --pulling the emergency brakes and damn the consequences.
It's as though people want to find the most dubious of non-existent connections and use that as leverage to besmirch something they don't like.
There are many things one can do where a person has no awareness of the tenuous connection but where you can have someone go back and then ex-post make that connection and declare that thing or person racist. It's a tactic.
Like one _could_ make the argument that factory automation in China is racist because without automation they would have to import labor from (some non-Chinese population). However, the Chinese never began automation with the intention of being racist.
Some may express societal challenges in ways that inappropriately and wrongly infer intentionality. We can acknowledge their point while strongly disagreeing with their characterization.
There are significant societal impacts of this AI buildout. Some are concerned externalities weigh more heavily on the poor and marginalized. I think state wide data center holds are part of this civil discourse.
I'd prefer we have more conservative pollution standards along with a reasonable tax on AI use that helps mitigate externalities. That's hard. Reasonable people can have fierce disagreements on what market interventions are indicated, and how extensive they should be.