logoalt Hacker News

sokolofftoday at 12:44 AM4 repliesview on HN

I can’t see a catalytic converter theft on a car parked on the street as burglary. Parked in a (private) garage? Yes, burglary. Parked on the street? No.

So, daytime theft of a converter from a car parked outside wouldn’t qualify I don’t think.


Replies

slashdevtoday at 1:31 AM

It also mentions:

> theft during the nighttime, or criminal mischief during the nighttime.

Seems like that qualifies

show 1 reply
nonethewisertoday at 1:08 AM

Parked in your driveway

show 1 reply
thaumasiotestoday at 1:04 AM

If you sleep in the car it will qualify no matter where you're parked. This also appears to be true of an RV or any vehicle that clearly accommodates sleeping.

For reference:

"Burglary" under the Texas penal code is defined by entering a habitation or any portion of a building that is not open to the public, either with the intent to commit a crime, or when followed by the actual commission of, or the attempt to commit, a crime.

"Robbery" is theft in which the thief causes an injury to someone else. (Or intentionally threatens to do so.)

"Theft" is what it sounds like.

Most notably burglary need not include any element of theft. I feel like it's a mistake for the legal code to distinguish between what are fully interchangeable terms in the language the code is supposedly written in.

On topic for this particular comment, "habitation" is specifically defined to include vehicles "adapted for the overnight accommodation of persons".

show 4 replies
timcobbtoday at 2:27 AM

What's the point of Texas, then? Maybe Florida?