logoalt Hacker News

reilly3000today at 5:37 PM4 repliesview on HN

I believe that agentic systems should require registered/licensed human operators and a set of standards for safe operation.


Replies

wjnctoday at 6:00 PM

As someone who read Milton Friedman to quite disliking professional licensing, this strikes me as a real US perspective (Louisiana florists and hair braiders come to mind). Plain old US tort law should do the trick.

In the same direction of your idea though: Why don’t the token factories have risk management and compliance departments? Multibillion dollar firms that stand to lose every penny if they hack and destroy any reasonable sized firm. I think these firms are the largest firms without proper corporate governance in humanities history. Move fast and break other peoples shit.

show 2 replies
Aurornistoday at 6:38 PM

> I believe that agentic systems should require registered/licensed human operators

Registering and getting a license to use an LLM? I can run these things on my local computer. Nothing good comes from trying to force registration and licensing other than taking away a lot of our freedoms and eliminating privacy all over.

Anyone with bad intentions will just VPN to another country to download the weights and run it locally, or use a compute provider in another country. That leaves the rest of us having to go through these performative registration and licensing hoops to do our basic work.

I also don’t see how open weight models would be compatible with a requirement to license and register, unless you believe we need to start requiring licensing and registration for things we do in private on our own computers?

show 1 reply
khueytoday at 6:44 PM

If the folks at OpenAI aren't qualified to be operating these systems who would be?

snomantoday at 7:09 PM

Create a permanent underclass that is unable to access intelligent machines. That’s remarkably dystopian of you.

show 1 reply