logoalt Hacker News

belvaltoday at 6:24 PM6 repliesview on HN

As a fervent Claude Code user who made the switch to GPT 5.6 Sol over Opus 5 over hard-to-read prose this makes me happy. I love your product but the current models are very hard to work with if you need to do a lot of context switching. Brevity is key.


Replies

dgellowtoday at 7:36 PM

Brevity means less output tokens, which doesn’t really align with the AI vendors incentives (unless there is a causal relationship with people switching, of course).

Though Claude 5 is not too verbose, it’s more like, full of incomprehensible jargon (even when you’re expert in the domain discussed!)

show 1 reply
pixl97today at 6:34 PM

>Brevity is key

Which is something the providers that are trying to watermark their texts can't afford. Superfluous replies give much more opportunity to further encode this junk information.

show 2 replies
darepublictoday at 6:38 PM

Also a codex user but for me brevity is not it's strong suit. I basically have to give it bigger tasks than I am used to to warrant the time it takes to complete. I feel whatever context the tooling adds can also be problematic

show 1 reply
okdood64today at 7:24 PM

I also switched to 5.6 Sol for this very reason. it was so exhausting and cringe to read.

lelanthrantoday at 7:12 PM

> Brevity is key.

I've found that models interpret "brevity" as "incomprehensible".

mihaelmtoday at 6:46 PM

Lets see what they do with Opus first. I didn't find Fable 5.0 prose that bad to read, but improvement is always welcome. It's Opus 5.0 that's atrocious.