logoalt Hacker News

mywittynametoday at 8:06 PM0 repliesview on HN

> fail closed

I understand fail closed to mean, be secure when in failure. And fail open to be continue to operate during a failure. A door that fails closed would not let anyone in; one that fails open lets everyone in.

But I can see how these are not the mutually exclusive definition the labels imply, especially if you apply the concept to entities that aren't doors or otherwise have explicit open/closed states. It's probably best to just be specific in those cases.

Similarly, open loop vs closed loop seems to trip people up enough that I no longer use it. But the confusion is understandable since "closed loop" being "has a feedback loop" sounds backwards. Which, is the same way it's being used in your fuse example; a "closed" fuse closes the circuit making it live. But it's still backwards from the colloquial usage, even if it's correct in that context.