logoalt Hacker News

_superposition_today at 7:56 PM9 repliesview on HN

I really wish it was called chain of instruction. Because it's definitely not thought.


Replies

minimaxirtoday at 8:18 PM

"Chain of Thoughts" is a term from the title of a 2022 research paper "Chain-of-Thought Prompting Elicits Reasoning in Large Language Models" (https://arxiv.org/abs/2201.11903), well before ChatGPT and the subsequent marketing hype. If anything, it's the most correct way to use the term.

show 1 reply
mgraczyktoday at 8:15 PM

this is needlessly pedantic

first, they are certainly not instructions so that is a much worse name

but more importantly, we use words in new contexts all the time. Do you object to calling the computer device "mouse" because it's not a mouse? how about "neural network"? "ignition" on an electric vehicle?

"cot" is no more misleading than thousands of words you use every day.

show 2 replies
arm32today at 8:03 PM

They’re intermediate tokens, so I wish we called it what it is… ITG. The anthropomorphizing is out of control.

show 4 replies
popupeyecaretoday at 8:11 PM

Maybe thoughts are just a chain of instructions in our head.

Angosturatoday at 8:02 PM

Chain Of Tokens

fookertoday at 8:21 PM

What is thought?

show 1 reply
lossolotoday at 8:17 PM

Yeah, basically they are using more computation to explore the solution space before producing the final answer.

ahofmanntoday at 8:08 PM

Everything around LLMs is blatantly misleading. There is no thought, there is no personality in those programs. I really despise how those tools are trained to sound like a person, or appearing as honest. The worst offender are the AI voices with their fake pauses, breathes and so on, which sound so convincing, while talking just false, sycophancy bullshit.