logoalt Hacker News

pfedaktoday at 1:26 AM2 repliesview on HN

You might want to check that your proposed solution works at all before suggesting the problem is trivial. What's the probability that the first die goes first with your numbers?

You also can't generally "and so on" constrained combinatorial arrangements like this.


Replies

margalabargalatoday at 2:13 AM

I certainly would have, had I suggested the problem trivial! I'll keep that in mind for if I suggest things are trivial rather than suggesting I lack understanding.

> You also can't generally "and so on" constrained combinatorial arrangements like this.

I know you can't generally but in the specific case I proposed you can (3 sets of 3, 4 sets of 4, 5 sets of 5, each dice taking one ordinal of each set).

You might want to check that your proposed generalization criticism applies to the generalization at all before suggesting the arrangement doesn't work :)

show 1 reply
cwillutoday at 1:39 AM

Saying “I'm having trouble understanding” is not the same thing as “this is trivial”.

show 2 replies