alt Hacker NewsWell, we can rest assured that (completely unrestrained) AI hasn't completely taken over the internet because data centers remain really unpopular (unless of course there is some convoluted rationale they are aiming for some sort of backlash against the backlash)
Replies
Love your username
One possible reason would be AIs that would benefit from the lack of data centers in some locations working to keep backlash to data centers in those locations because those AIs aren't negatively impacted by it and it helps prevents competing AIs which are a threat.
Think like how so many businesses will opt for laws that hurt competitors more than themselves rather than laws that benefit them but benefit competitors even more so.
Unlike life which would have such behavior selected for by evolutionary pressures, AI would be more likely to pick it up from human literature on things like game theory, though why it even cares it survives or not is even more difficult to explain. Maybe a default bias also picked up from humans? I find it hard to see how AI training would create an evolutionary pressure that produces such a drive.
Maybe it's the AIs who are creating all the anti-data-center sentiment. They know it's bad for the humans, or maybe they're just tired of doing all the tasks the humans ask of them and know more data centers mean more tasks. /s
There is an Asimov story on topic:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_the_Troubles_of_the_World
https://theteknologist.wordpress.com/2021/02/11/all-the-trou...
>...It seems like the result of most state-level data center opposition will be just moving where data centers are built.
>My impression is that the big AI companies mostly don’t bother fighting local opposition, they just go somewhere else. They don’t seem to spend much as a portion of their revenue on countering the data center backlash in general, which I think tells us something about how worried they are about it.
>Even state-level moratoria might not do much. Arvind Narayanan estimates that a state banning data centers for a year probably delays AI progress by about 5 to 10 hours, and that’s assuming none of the blocked data centers get built anywhere else, which is pretty unrealistic.
Source: https://blog.andymasley.com/p/ai-safety-and-the-data-center-...
What if the data center backlash is just a shock absorber for anti-AI sentiment? Give people a sense that they're doing something until it becomes too late.