logoalt Hacker News

drewg123today at 5:52 PM7 repliesview on HN

However, Strike 3 argues that this is no ordinary home pirate, using the timing of the downloads as evidence. On March 20, 2025, the porn producer’s general counsel first emailed Meta’s lawyers with forensic evidence of BitTorrent activity on the tech giant’s corporate IP addresses.

“Just hours later, Strike 3 first recorded BitTorrent infringement on John Doe’s residential IP Address,” the motion reads.

“This may suggest that Meta desired to shift infringing activity to this hidden residential IP Address in order to prevent further detection,”

Seems like there are 2 different reads to that. (a) is like they say, and Meta was using porn for AI training or something else official. Or (b) that he was personally downloading porn either at the office or a corp VPN and was told to stop by their corp It folks..


Replies

gchamonlivetoday at 8:54 PM

> b) that he was personally downloading porn either at the office or a corp VPN and was told to stop by their corp It folks..

I wonder how much porn you have to personally download to be considered prolific.

EDIT: "Reality Labs executive downloaded nearly 20,000 files at his home for work purposes"

Yeah, you can't consume that much porn for your own amusement.

show 3 replies
stevenwootoday at 6:00 PM

When I worked for office with about 40 employees in 2001 or so, the FBI came to our office to arrest a guy using I think Limewire over our high speed internet access to share music and videos. It may be so common these days they only crack down like that on really egregious abuse.

show 5 replies
ryandvmtoday at 6:01 PM

> Or (b) that he was personally downloading porn either at the office or a corp VPN

Man, if Facebook is hiring people this dumb, it's going to make me feel a lot worse about getting rejected after interviewing there.

show 12 replies
read_the_articltoday at 6:59 PM

From TFA: "Strike 3 suggests the downloads are consistent with work to make the headset compatible with adult films"

> The company logged all BitTorrent activity detected from the executive’s connection, which was nearly 20,000 files.

> This includes VR adult titles made for Meta’s Quest headset. Strike 3 suggests the downloads are consistent with work to make the headset compatible with adult films.

> As recently as August 25, Strike 3 says it recorded more than 150 daily downloads, from multi-language “Mega Packs” of TV shows, movies, software and books to what it describes as AI-generated pornography and VR adult films. That included nearly a dozen of its own titles.

show 1 reply
huijzertoday at 7:32 PM

> Meta was using porn for AI training or …

Seems plausible. The material contains many hours of highly detailed human interaction plus I don’t expect Meta would have moral objections given their track record.

show 2 replies
jasonlotitotoday at 7:38 PM

> "In short, this is a lot for one person to torrent on an average day, particularly one who has a demanding job," Strike 3 writes. The company believes the pattern makes more sense as AI training data or research.

I hope they drag Meta hard and get every penny for this.

mc32today at 5:57 PM

IT is usually not the one doing the enforcement. They typically only do the monitoring and may report some activity above thresholds.

Legal is usually the one initiating then engaging with HR to do enforcement.