logoalt Hacker News

Sharlintoday at 3:53 PM9 repliesview on HN

And tobacco. And leaded gasoline. And...

We really are one fucked up species. But can evolution even produce anything better? Anything that's not so prone to coordination problems?

https://slatestarcodex.com/2014/07/30/meditations-on-moloch/


Replies

customguytoday at 4:01 PM

No, these are really fucked up people, to leap from that to "the species" and from that to "evolution" which humans had no clue about even hundreds of years ago... is just avoiding confronting that and them. It's half of the the reason for why these things happen and get worse, a sort of global bystander effect. We feel okay to in public dismiss this.

If you were one in a group of 4 people, and one of them fed poison to a child to remove a stain from their shoe, or just for a laugh, or for 2 cents, and someone got upset, would you talk about the species or evolution first thing? What habit did we normalise here?

show 4 replies
traviswingotoday at 3:58 PM

I’ve long suspected it’ll take us _almost_ going extinct to actually take this stuff seriously.

There are too few of us who understand asymmetric risk, and too many in power who are willing to roll the dice for the entire species for profit.

Realistically, it will have to get much, much, worse before it gets any better.

IMO this is part of the natural evolutionary cycle.

culitoday at 4:35 PM

Asbestos too. And glyphosates which have devastated insect populations. Veritasium did great documentaries on both of those crises

glyphosate https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CxVXvFOPIyQ

asbestos https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cMx139eTxoc

It took decades for the science to finally flow freely since both of these industries heavily targeted the scientific institutions themselves. Who knows what other pesticides and chemical companies are following the same playbook that we won't get to know about for decades.

show 1 reply
mitthrowaway2today at 4:18 PM

The only species I can think of that coordinate better than humans do are ants, bees, and naked mole rats.

tracerbulletxtoday at 3:57 PM

We're our own moral judges. Biology doesn't have an ethical opinion.

show 1 reply
someothherguyytoday at 4:00 PM

cheater detection and self-correction is important in systems. i am not sure "fucked-up" is a meaningful way to look at species-level things.

show 2 replies
rTX5CMRXIfFGtoday at 4:02 PM

Oh, evolution certainly can. The bad ones always get killed off.

show 1 reply
clickety_clacktoday at 4:24 PM

…gambling, social media…

cute_boitoday at 5:01 PM

there is reason why every civilization rise and fails.