logoalt Hacker News

andlarrytoday at 3:18 PM9 repliesview on HN

Here is the State Department's rationale: https://www.state.gov/releases/office-of-the-spokesperson/20...


Replies

linuxhansltoday at 5:08 PM

Never heard of A/I and I have no idea what they are about, but rather than a government communication this statement reads like an angry rant with lots of unhelpful name-calling.

I would expect a government to be professional and just stick to the (proven) facts and avoiding labels; that would also be more convincing. Oh well.

show 3 replies
alexwebb2today at 4:14 PM

I’m not familiar with A/I, but this sounds pretty damning – the ideological vetting of users in particular seems to discount any sort of neutral utility defense.

show 9 replies
madsmithtoday at 5:38 PM

Unfortunately I can no longer take any official communication from my government at face value. They have lost my trust that they are operating as directed by the letter of the law without fear nor favor.

bambaxtoday at 5:06 PM

"violent" is used many times in this announcement, but it would seem that one of the most violent entity in the world right now are the US? Also, it's so weird that "antifa" (antifascists) has become a bad thing. If antifa is bad then it must mean "fa" is good? So we should bring back the Nazis?

The "Western hemisphere" (which, of course, is neither) tolerates the US and the way it enforces its decisions outside its own borders, because it used to provide some assurance of stability and protection. But as the US rescinds that policy, weakens Nato, declares a tariffs war to every country on earth, etc., there will be less and less justification as well as, probably (hopefully) less and less public acceptance for any of this posturing.

show 2 replies
sphtoday at 3:34 PM

Like trying to scrutinize the motives of a complete lunatic.

show 2 replies
fastballtoday at 5:10 PM

> A/I’s cadre of radical hackers and tech developers provide a full spectrum of services

Pun intended?

hirako2000today at 4:12 PM

> ERR_UNEXPECTED_PROXY_AUTH

computomatictoday at 4:09 PM

Most of this has me rolling my eyes (“cadre of radical hackers”? really?), but this part is interesting:

> The A/I Collective… manually vets all potential users for ideological affinity before granting them access to its infrastructure.

What is the truth behind that? Such behaviour would undermine A/I’s claim they are akin to Gmail if they explicitly are not a neutral ISP. After that, it becomes a question of degrees: what were their specific criteria for access to the platform?

Asking out of genuine curiosity. I wasn’t familiar with this group before today.

show 1 reply
vrganjtoday at 4:10 PM

Basically, far right extremists targeting antifascists through mechanisms of political repression while having the gall to call themselves pro free speech.

show 6 replies