logoalt Hacker News

alkonauttoday at 8:31 AM1 replyview on HN

The long tail of ms Excel does not get replaced easily. For 90% of customers and 90% of workflows you see either no use of a program, or use cases that can be replaced with anything.

But eventually you'll find the power users who do business critical stuff in excel sheets that you notice can't be done in any other way, and if you stop doing it then people aren't paid in time or whatever.

This doesn't mean it's a good idea to not try this. But Microsoft also aren't dumb. They know exactly how common this is, and what fraction this is. And they will make sure that it costs little more to keep the Microsoft products across the org, than it costs to keep them for specific users and deal with the mess that happens.

This could be said for other things than Excel, but Excel has been one of those moats for decades now.


Replies

72deluxetoday at 8:58 AM

But the general usage of Excel is so negligible in terms of using its actual features that it can be easily replaced.

In my experience, non-basic formulas are beyond 99% of people and they use it simply for adding stuff up in a grid. This is why Google Sheets is used in many places as a replacement (even if it balloons RAM usage when presented with a large sheet of data), simply because all of the wonderful features of Excel are unused.

The most complex operation some people do seems to be lookup tables.