logoalt Hacker News

shotoday at 5:35 AM1 replyview on HN

The joke is that macs are famously slow at prompt prefill and you are not getting anything back in 3 seconds, or probably even 30. Once they get generating, it can be acceptable, but the TTFT is horrendous.

There's a ton of well-understood things Apple can and hopefully will do to massively accelerate every stage of this pipeline and hopefully they're hard at work implementing most of them for m7.


Replies

EagnaIonattoday at 7:56 AM

> The joke is that macs are famously slow at prompt prefill and you are not getting anything back in 3 seconds.

Your knowledge is out of date. In truth it depends on the Mac and the models used.

I asked this question on M5 Max 128GB, using Ollama model Quen3.8:27b-mlx, with thinking enabled.

Question: "Give me a python code snippet that opens a file and sorts the lines of text. "

In 2.4 seconds it gave me 4 examples that work with different sorting configurations and a summary of when to use each.

Compare that to an older model of gpt-oss:20b, took 5 seconds to finish thinking and 2 seconds to stream the answer. It gave me one python example snippet and two one liners that do the same thing.

show 1 reply