logoalt Hacker News

evil-olivetoday at 5:43 PM2 repliesview on HN

> But until now, each machine needed a separate Herdr client, usually in a different terminal tab. You had to remember where each agent was running and switch between those tabs to check on them. That was the bottleneck.

is it, though?

I can imagine having a local Herdr instance and one running on a remote box somewhere, but I can't think of a use case where I'm trying to juggle N different Herdr instances and that overhead becomes a meaningful bottleneck.

> Getting to 1.0

> After this update, what I want is to make connecting those machines more convenient. You shouldn’t need to think about SSH or deal with complicated network setup. It should be easy to connect any machine, anywhere, through one Herdr account.

(emphasis added)

sigh. I'm a daily user of Herdr. I don't have a Herdr account today. I don't want a Herdr account. I don't need a Herdr account.

the product is not even to 1.0 yet and already the writing is on the wall for the path towards enshittification & acquisition by $bigco.

of course, I'm sure there will be some "usage without an account will still work" platitudes, but the trend of development is clearly going to be in the direction of features that "integrate" with the "developers using Herdr pay us money and/or we collect their data" business model.


Replies

threecheesetoday at 6:32 PM

Same. If asked to create an account, I suspect a lot of us will decline and move on.

The reason Herdr is novel, IMO, is its runtime owns the PTYs and builds a bidirectional messaging system on top of that. It’s like Pi’s RPC - a very limited version of it - which allows one to hook into agent i/o without needing to invoke “$agentcli -p”. There’s a lot they could build on that, and so I wonder why a managed cloud play was first on their list.

well_ackshuallytoday at 6:15 PM

>the product is not even to 1.0 yet and already the writing is on the wall for the path towards enshittification & acquisition by $bigco.

https://herdr.dev/blog/herdr-is-joining-y-combinator/

On the wall ? It's spray painted in big neon letters, and by themselves, lmao. Herdr cannot be trusted.