logoalt Hacker News

matherialtoday at 1:16 AM5 repliesview on HN

Unlike most other commenters, I applaud him for acting on his principles. If you sincerely believe that, of course you should act. You might not succeed, but your voice might be the one that tips the scales and starts a broader movement.

This doesn't mean I agree with him. The fears of doomsday caused by rapid takeoff have been with us since day 1 and the mechanism is always basically "AI invents magic that sets it free of any physical constraints". Self-replicating sentient nanobots or something like that. I think there's plenty to be worried about with AI, but runaway scenarios are pretty low on my list.


Replies

copperxtoday at 2:49 AM

To borrow on the 1990s Slashdot meme:

1. Invent transformer architecture.

2. Scale it up.

3. ???

4. Machines become sentient and kill us all.

OpenAI and Anthropic pinky promise that they have figured out #3 and they're not BSing just to get more funding, no.

But because we live in a culture of fear, everyone eats it up no questions asked.

show 4 replies
sssilvertoday at 4:14 AM

I wonder whether he's vested any options, and whether he's exercised them.

matthewfcarlsontoday at 1:18 AM

Agreed. Granted I just read the Reverse Centaur book, so I’m still coming off that skeptical viewpoint but it’s hard not to see this as hype. But I will always respect someone for doing what they think is right.

kennywinkertoday at 2:40 AM

Now is a great time to watch Colossus: The Forbin Project.

show 2 replies
whateveraccttoday at 3:46 AM

the AI-pilled exec at my job already (a few weeks ago) declared out of nowhere that we are in the rapid takeoff scenario lol. he must have gotten high on twitter kool-aid and posted on company slack to self-soothe.