logoalt Hacker News

cataparttoday at 2:13 PM3 repliesview on HN

same. none of the available prompts are what I would prompt claude with and I get way better results than this. makes sense to me why the provided prompts result in the simulated outcomes. garbage in, garbage out.


Replies

madibo3156today at 2:37 PM

Part skeptic and part zetetic, what prompt would you have used?

My impression is that this is an oversimplified demonstration of what can happen when you prompt Claude in a system with many more variables (than two buttons and two colours).

If I want the button to turn blue and that's it, what instead do I ask? Even in a complicated system with many levers, what do I request other than the desired end result, hoping that Claude pulls the right levers to produce something acceptably close to what I think I asked for?

show 2 replies
mort96today at 2:51 PM

It "makes sense" that plainly telling the chat bot to make one button blue makes the whole site blue? It "makes sense" that correcting it and repeating 3 times that no, only the one button should be blue, should make the button a gradient and start a philosophical discussion around the nature of "blue"?

Wow, you AI people really have a negative view of the technology y'all are trying to sell as the next Jesus

show 2 replies
selestifytoday at 4:08 PM

So how would you prompt it instead? Because that's exactly how I prompt it, because any reasonable human being would know exactly what I mean by "Make the shopping button blue", and I am sick and tired of getting shitty results.

show 1 reply