logoalt Hacker News

ccotoday at 5:47 PM5 repliesview on HN

Extend the Stem!!

I have no idea why Apple has made AirPods harder to handle, impaired mic placement, and limited the battery capacity with shorter stems.

The longer stems offered more room for battery, got the mic closer to your mouth, and were so much easier to handle, manipulate etc.

Can't really fathom why they shortened the stem and made it harder for everyone, themselves and users alike.


Replies

jandrewrogerstoday at 7:07 PM

I assume the long stem increases the likelihood it will be dislodged from the ear because it increases torque at the point of contact when moving. The first AirPods were much less secure in the ear than current ones. Reducing stem length may lower the risk of them falling out.

The long stem may have been a necessary but suboptimal engineering tradeoff to get the first version out the door. A lot of design tweaks have gone into making AirPods less likely to fall out.

afavourtoday at 5:56 PM

Personally I prefer it. Less chance of accidentally knocking them out.

cjtoday at 5:48 PM

Aesthetics. Short stem looks sleeker.

Form vs. function

show 3 replies
ksectoday at 6:41 PM

>Extend the Stem!!

Same thought as well. It doesn't have to be much bigger, but even 10% longer would be much more useful from mic placement and battery perspective.

loloquwowndueotoday at 5:48 PM

It’s Apple so the answer is clear: shorter stems look nicer. Functionality be damned. You’re holding it wrong my dude. Nobody wants to look like they have q-tips in their ears.

show 4 replies