logoalt Hacker News

amazingamazingtoday at 12:38 AM7 repliesview on HN

You base this off what? We really live in a post truth society where innocent asks for evidence supporting a claim are discouraged.

I am not saying it stolen, merely asking if there is any proof it was bought. And no, “oCcAms rAZOr” is not evidence.


Replies

csallentoday at 12:40 AM

This comment and others like it are wild to me.

Since when was the default to assume malicious activity and victimization, and then to ask for proof otherwise? Obviously we should do the reverse. There should be evidence of theft rather than assuming theft as the baseline.

For starters, if the band's handles were taken non-consensually, then the least we should expect is a public complaint from said band.

This is doubly true in a world where social media handles are routinely bought, sold, and traded. And triply true where the supposed victim of this crime is an incredibly popular group of people with an extremely massive platform, and it's 99.9999% likely that Meta knew this going in.

show 3 replies
bradlytoday at 12:44 AM

This is from an app the was also named Muse:

> An opportunity came up regarding the Muse name and trademarks. These have now been sold, so I need to move the app to a new name. Nothing else about the company, the app, your account, or your data has changed.

From https://allume.com/allume-faq/

Waterluviantoday at 12:40 AM

Probably nothing. But Meta throwing a boatload of money at Muse is probably cheaper and easier than being evil about it.

The problem is, it’s Meta. And like the scorpion said to the frog, “I can’t help it. It’s my nature.”

rcontitoday at 12:56 AM

The fact that the band changed their handles months ago and haven't complained? Occam's razor, man.

vmg12today at 12:52 AM

my reason for believing they were paid is that the band has not been making a stink about it

lazyasciiarttoday at 12:39 AM

Knowing that people are willing to exchange social handles for money.

show 1 reply
sippingabonedrytoday at 12:44 AM

Well in a decent society you can't take things that aren't yours.

Nobody using Muse the tool knows or gives a fuck who Muse the band is, the band itself is twice their age.

At 32 years a band is reaching Spinal Tap stage and they could probably use the cash. Occam's razor and all that.

show 3 replies