logoalt Hacker News

Espressosaurustoday at 11:48 AM2 repliesview on HN

How does this work in two party consent states? It seems nuts on the face of it.

I guess they devolve liability onto the user and wash their hands of it?


Replies

bryanrasmussentoday at 12:08 PM

it works, in an American context, because the states would have to take it to court and determine if this actually fell under the rules of making a recording.

Argument for, there is no recording stored anywhere thus it does not need consent.

Argument against, there is obviously a recording made. A recording is made and transmitted between devices and Apple and afterwards deleted, that this happens almost real time as the conversation does not change the fact a recording exists for some short time.

Probably Argument for wins, but assume at some point the transcriptions become nearly perfect then expect it to be litigated again.

show 1 reply
j16sdiztoday at 12:00 PM

It is "not stored" "not recorded".

show 1 reply