logoalt Hacker News

noir_lordyesterday at 8:03 PM1 replyview on HN

Dogfooding is useful certainly but it can also be a trap, as someone who is technical and knows how the software works both sides you can fall into the trap of avoiding triggering the exact kind of issues a regular user can walk into.

Your conceptual model of how things work is going to be different to that persons and it is a very hard trap not to fall into.


Replies

variagayesterday at 8:19 PM

Indeed. Some of the worst software interfaces I've ever dealt with were fully "dogfooded" and that was the cause; the people writing the software did use it every day but (a) in a very idiosyncratic way and (b) in a specific, very constrained environment.

The devs did use the software, but used it in such a different way from everyone else that when the devs optimized for their own case, it made the software actively worse for everyone else.

show 1 reply