logoalt Hacker News

omnicognatetoday at 7:51 PM1 replyview on HN

It's not a simple matter of "becoming good at", and yes, I could very well have similar concerns, depending on how it impacts the field. The statement itself mentions that such concerns exist in many other fields.

I doubt OpenAI will take such a combative stance and accuse these mathematicians of "demanding" things, as you do. As I said, the purpose of this is marketing and the statement simultaneously undermines the value of that marketing (showing these projects as irresponsible) and gives these companies an even better piece of marketing in its place: "our AI got so good at maths the mathematicians begged us to stop". It's entirely possible they will stop pouring millions into these projects.


Replies

mosuratoday at 8:02 PM

So let’s say OpenAI cure cancer and put every cancer researcher out of work depriving them of intellectual satisfaction, this would also be a problem? It would certainly impact the field.

The fact is these fields are supported by society because of the benefits to everyone else. Once the same results can be achieved in a cheaper and faster way that is what will be done. We should mourn this in the same way we do buggy whip manufacturers. Again people still ride horses.

show 2 replies