logoalt Hacker News

elmer2today at 1:15 AM2 repliesview on HN

I don't think this true. If I throw a brick out my window and it hurts someone, I can still be held criminially liable, even if I didn't mean to do it.

Do drunk drivers intionally kill people on the road?


Replies

dghlsakjgtoday at 1:42 AM

Not a lawyer, but the other responder definitely isn’t either.

Whether intent is required is down to how the law is written. For many offenses “strict liability” applies, where intent is not required, they only have to prove you did it, not what your intent was.

DUI is typically a strict liability crime. They don’t need to prove that you intended to drive drunk, only that you did drive drunk.

show 2 replies
CGamesPlaytoday at 1:34 AM

Intent is the difference between murder and manslaughter, in that case. Drunk driving is common enough that prosecutors will argue that getting drunk in a situation where you have to drive is intent. Get OpenAI convicted of unintentional CFAA first, then say that the negligence qualifies as intent, I suppose.