logoalt Hacker News

sho_hntoday at 4:16 AM1 replyview on HN

This grossly understimates the risk, imho. The problem with LLM runs is that people run programs without knowing the outcome beforehand, with a large potential set of outcomes unlike any other class of program we've run at this scale before. In the interaction with other systems (since we also give them far-ranging access, very nice hardware, and run them often), bad things can happen.

It's like running potentially buggy code - or an well-biased fuzzer -, but at massive scale, and code that can self-modify and self-expand. "Alignment" is just a way to describe aggregate statistics about their runtime behavior.

They don't need to be intelligent, or alive, or "more than token prediction engines" for this. They just need to happen to end up making the wrong API calls without the operator seeing it coming. No virus has a brain, yet they can be very bad for you.

I understand that some people get turned off by anthropomorpization or scifi language. Fine! But don't turn off your engineering brain over it.


Replies

z0rtoday at 4:23 AM

This is the motte and bailey fallacy. Yes, LLMs can do harm by making the wrong API calls. No, LLMs are not going to do the things implied by the comment I responded to above.

show 4 replies