logoalt Hacker News

auggierosetoday at 8:10 AM4 repliesview on HN

> Peer in peer-reviewed is a logical coherent and functional definition with answers.

What is the definition? If you tell me that, then I might be able to tell you if it is logical coherent and functional, I have a PhD in computational logic.


Replies

athrowaway3ztoday at 1:05 PM

Something like this sketch work for you?

peer(X, 0) :- founding_peer(X).

electorate(T, count<Y>) :- peer(Y, T).

support(X, T, count<Y>) :- candidate(X), peer(Y, T), recognizes(Y, X, T+1).

peer(X, T+1) :- support(X, T, Votes), electorate(T, Total), 2 * Votes > Total.

da_chickentoday at 8:46 AM

Amongst all this rhetorical brush-beating, what were you trying to teach the snakes?

raverbashingtoday at 10:41 AM

> I have a PhD in computational logic.

And you don't know how the peer-review system works?

Just a hunch but Claude saying your work is "PhD level" does not count

wokwokwoktoday at 9:14 AM

Your (many) replies on this topic are being down voted for a reason; please either post substantive comments or stop.

show 1 reply