logoalt Hacker News

CuriouslyCtoday at 3:23 PM1 replyview on HN

> AI music is not and cannot be inspirational. It's the absolute opposite of it. And serious musicians know it.

So, your answer to "people are doing a thing" is to just say "no they're not! NANANANA can't hear you!"

Musicians have claimed to take inspiration from things like water dripping from a leaky faucet and machine sounds, so your claim that AI outputs can't inspire artists is farcical.

You're obviously biased beyond the point of being able to share in a nuanced discourse, the next few years are gonna be SO rough for you, sorry to say. Buckle up.


Replies

dofmtoday at 3:35 PM

> Musicians have claimed to take inspiration from things like water dripping from a leaky faucet and machine sounds

I don't think you really understand how this very concept undermines your argument.

If I saw an artist making creative non-AI work critiquing AI, or even using AI to pointedly critique AI, I would feel differently about that.

But I don't think you understand the core concepts here at all.

> You're obviously biased beyond the point of being able to share in a nuanced discourse, the next few years are gonna be SO rough for you, sorry to say. Buckle up.

This AI industry wizard-of-nihilism tosh gets so old. I am sure you think you're wise and informed and on some kind of nihilist high ground for saying it, though.

show 1 reply