alt Hacker NewsNo I’m not talking about runtime conversions. I’m talking about conversions that happen at type inference time.
Rust is not a subtyping based language, except for traits and lifetimes. So statements like never being at the bottom of the type hierarchy is irrelevant here even though it is correct. If Rust had higher rank types the never type is also (forall a. a) but still it doesn’t matter. It is simply surprising for a type to be converted implicitly according to subtyping rules other than for traits and lifetimes.
Replies
Let's avoid using the term "subtyping", which as you say is irrelevant here. The reason you need diverging functions to satisfy arbitrary type obligations (i.e. to coerce to any other type) is because otherwise anything as simple as `let x = Some(42); x.unwrap();` just completely fails to compile, because `unwrap` is internally just:
fn unwrap<T>(t: Option<T>) -> T {
match t {
Some(foo) => foo,
None => panic!()
}
}
Do you have an example of a piece of code that behaves in a surprising way because of this rule?