logoalt Hacker News

roenxitoday at 5:39 AM2 repliesview on HN

My point is the article claimed it would show evidence of something when in fact it did not. It should either not have bothered to include evidence or found better evidence


Replies

gilleaintoday at 10:21 AM

Evidence such as this quote?

> an extremely arrogant demeanour instead of the modest gait and bearing proper to the gentle sex

That is, the 'Gesta Stephani' is claiming that she should not be arrogant because it is not proper, because she is a woman.

That evidence?

show 1 reply
scott_wtoday at 6:13 AM

Er… no it didn’t? It just said the criticism being based on her womanhood was evident because of <reason>, it never promised to prove it, it was just a rhetorical device and they expect the reader to know the information already.

If you want to learn more about early medieval attitudes to women and power in England, it’s on you to learn, not on the article to triple its length to prove every minor claim.

show 1 reply