logoalt Hacker News

XCancel Taken Down Again

56 pointsby gaganyaantoday at 9:51 AM59 commentsview on HN

Comments

ocdtoday at 10:45 AM

I don't see how any government or business (especially the former) can justify using X at this point when it doesn't serve the public interest or the interest of customers who deserve at least some choice. It's as unreasonable for them as using Instagram or a dating app for something intended for broad reach and accessibility.

I don't particularly like Bluesky, but it's publicly readable and has RSS. Any real solution would be protocol or standard instead of yet another closed service, though. For now, I see Nitter and XCancel as a temporary fix until people abandon it for whatever practical, economic, or political reason(s) they may have.

simondotautoday at 10:11 AM

If you don’t like X, I don’t understand why anyone would use a service like XCancel, which effectively helps maintain the cultural relevance of X.

On a practical level, I’m also wondering what consistent legal standard people want when it comes to things like terms of service and individuals' copyright. It's unworkable to maintain one rule for the awesome people we might like and and another rule for the horrible despots we might not like.

show 9 replies
cube00today at 10:05 AM

The fact that so many large companies are still on X is so wrong.

show 3 replies
ArtTimeInvestortoday at 10:42 AM

When I read this, the Arweave project [1] comes to mind.

Isn't this the exact use case it was built for, preservation of news data in a way that it cannot be tampered with and so that it is kept accessible for everyone forever?

[1] https://arweave.org/

gaganyaantoday at 9:53 AM

XCancel service is suspended.

Unfortunately, due to a new development in the ongoing legal proceedings, we are required to suspend this service again until further notice. We can't share more details.

You can find the content you were looking for on the original website:

Continue to X

Thank you for your understanding. And the trust you have put into the XCancel project.

throwa356262today at 10:15 AM

Proposal:

Set up a mastodon account that mirrors your (or someone elses) X account.

This way people who want can continue using X, and other people can read & refer to their posts without needing to log into X.

show 1 reply
okeuro49today at 10:33 AM

I wish X would allow browsing threads, which is the only reason I use xcancel.

I wouldn't even mind seeing advertisements.

I just don't want to have an X account.

aucisson_masquetoday at 10:13 AM

What was the Chinese alternative ? At this point I’m just going to use that instead, lawyers won’t be able to take that down.

chinathrowtoday at 10:30 AM

Has anyone ever succeeded going up against Elon legally?

mitxelatoday at 10:23 AM

There are now about 10 different people running them, and you can also run your own. https://status.d420.de/

The browser extension "Libredirect" will transparently redirect you to a working one or one of your choice.

poguetoday at 10:08 AM

Any details about what's going on? Is Nitter/their Github still up?

solarkrafttoday at 10:28 AM

So X is down again. Oh well.

lapkaaaatoday at 10:08 AM

Why would anyone use any xitter service voluntarily at this point

show 1 reply
darkwi11owtoday at 10:07 AM

Another "victory" for the freedom of information.

krembotoday at 10:14 AM

Not a popular question here, but what's the difference between xcancel or archive.org, and torrents and other pirate services alike? (except twitter is user content, yet per their tos xcancel is still piracy)

show 2 replies
_giorgio_today at 10:08 AM

[flagged]

show 4 replies