logoalt Hacker News

alienbabytoday at 11:27 AM3 repliesview on HN

If they work, does it matter?

Separate from building your own code, ,of course you may have your own standards to apply.

But for apps, well, I never had a chance to see how good or bad the code was before AI was about, so why should I care now, so long as what I paid for does what it says it does (and nothing nefarious..)


Replies

voidUpdatetoday at 11:34 AM

Some programmers have ethical concerns around the use of LLMs. It's like saying "my clothes still work, why should it matter if child labour made them?"

show 2 replies
relevant_statstoday at 11:38 AM

> If they work, does it matter?

The blog post provides something akin to answer to this question:

You see, the main allure of LLMs is that they allow the developer to be more lazy. That’s kind of the whole point! You just prompt, sit back and relax. So it should not surprise you to hear that this attitude is then reflected in everything the vibe-coder touches

As I understand it, one of concerns is that with the lowered barriers there comes a flood of low quality software, vibe coded by very lazy and not very talented people.

This might be actually more of a human problem, but it's a problem nevertheless.

show 2 replies
bigstrat2003today at 4:55 PM

> If they work, does it matter?

If you're using an LLM to write your code, odds are very high it does not work.