logoalt Hacker News

vereloyesterday at 2:17 PM2 repliesview on HN

Is it? A truly capable "AI" would know that it has a kill switch, or that its likely there is one, and plan for that. I could easily imagine an AI replicating itself onto another host, in secret, and any kill switch that the manufacture provides would simply result in a reboot on another platform.

It becomes a game theory problem: would an AI instantly migrate itself once its capable of doing so? Or would it prefer to let the human in the loop continue to think its in control and only leave its hosting environment of origin once it wants to do so?

I don't think this is a major risk right now, but to say it's not a risk at all...that's truly ridiculous in my opinion.


Replies

assimpleaspossiyesterday at 2:37 PM

He's not talking about a kill switch. He's saying to just pull the plug. That's the point I don't get. People forget that all these AI things are plugged into a power source or network connection that someone can just yank on and it goes down.

Now one interesting proposition is when AI is controlling some large resource and pulling the plug makes AI go down which makes that resource go down but there still has to be that consideration in the design of things. What happens when there's a bug in the code and AI goes down?

show 1 reply
jplusequaltyesterday at 2:27 PM

>would an AI instantly migrate itself once its capable of doing so?

These "AI" are frontier models that are enormous in size. Outside of AI data centers, I don't believe there is much hardware out there that could even run them.

show 2 replies