logoalt Hacker News

pronyesterday at 3:44 PM1 replyview on HN

It's disclosed right there in my profile (I don't see your professional affiliation disclosed in your comment; or your profile, for that matter). Of course, I, like other runtime and compiler people, joined the Java team because we wanted to work on the most advanced compiler and runtime tech. I perfectly understand people who want to work on smaller, newer, potentially insurgent products, but I took the chance to work on the cutting edge of compiler and runtime engineering, and Java is where it's at these days (I'm not saying it's the only one, but it's a very small club).


Replies

wk_endyesterday at 6:38 PM

GP's snark is unwarranted, but it's probably good practice to disclose your professional affiliation explicitly in comments related to it, even if you have already disclosed it in your profile.

I was reading your comments on Java, nodding my head, upvoting, without checking your profile and realizing that you're a member of the Java team. Knowing that doesn't mean I now suddenly disagree with you or anything. But while in an ideal world it doesn't matter who's saying something when evaluating it, there's some human factors at play - I'd like to turn up my internal sense of skepticism when dealing with someone, effectively, selling something their salary depends on; even if you're being entirely earnest, it's ultimately a sales pitch, and I feel bamboozled for not recognizing it - that'd make me appreciate transparency.

(FWIW, even though I prefer being coy about my place-of-work, I have no professional relation to this conversation. I've never used Java in my 9-5 and I haven't even really used it in earnest since, like, version 5 back in high school. I think it's always been underrated by the hacker crowd, though!)

show 2 replies