logoalt Hacker News

lrvickyesterday at 6:04 PM1 replyview on HN

Sure, a very smart and patient human could write this by hand in a long enough time horizon and unlimited budget. I should have said impossible in any realistic amount of time any responsible sponsor or employer would pay for.


Replies

nicebyteyesterday at 6:21 PM

I'm sorry, this is simply not true.

this https://codeberg.org/lrvick/nit/src/branch/main/src/system/r...

is textbook definition of boilerplate. you need to be patient to cross-reference syscall tables but certainly not smart.

Again, students learning about operating systems do similar things as a normal part of their education process.

I'm not saying LLMs wouldn't help with this (in fact, this is the type of thing that becomes pretty much a no-op with them) but the notion that this is "impossible by any realistic standards" is risible, and if you have actually contributed to the kernel like you say, you should know better.

show 1 reply