alt Hacker NewsWhich features exactly? Java got exhaustive pattern matching before C# (through sealed interfaces), it has switch expressions, multi-line strings, green threads and structured concurrency, is getting value types, and even type classes in the work.
Replies
Granted, I havent' used either for a couple of years, so my knowledge is a little rusty. Yes, some of them are "just syntax sugar", but man oh man does it make C# such a pleasant language to work with.
Used to work at a company which had services both in Java and C#, so some of Java's decisions or indecisions felt like pain points when switching between the two:
- Proper IEnumerable with proper iterators that in turn enables Linq (but in general permeates everything and is insanely easy to use and build upon). E.g. building an async service that behaves like an IEnumerable? Implement two methods.
Collection is halfway there, but I honestly cannot remember what was irking me about it in comparison to C#.
- Properties. Yeah, yeah, sealed classes, records and all that. Often you still need plain old classes.
- object initialisers. Which makes constructing anything a breeze. And on top of that you don't need manual .of methods for anything Colleciton-like if it'sa an IEnumerable.
- extension methods.
- named and optional arguments in functions
- null coalescing operator
- generics over primitive types (unless it was already implemented, I remember seeing a JEP about it)
- async/await. Yes, I know: different approaches to concurrency and all that. A lot of unnecessary verbiage could still probably be hidden behind a friendlier syntax.
- (sadly impossible in JVM to type erasure, only including this because I remember needing it many moons ago) generics metadata in runtime
- .... definitely a bunch more I don't remember at this point ...
Typeclasses caught me by surprise. Smart move by the java team.