logoalt Hacker News

foxglacieryesterday at 6:12 PM2 repliesview on HN

[flagged]


Replies

abustamamyesterday at 7:32 PM

> your faith is also a political institution

This is half-right. Islam does have its own political system, but the faith is largely divorced from that system.

I'm fairly active in my mosque and ive met a lot of community members running for various levels of public office. None of them are calling for Islamic jurisprudence, and none of the policies they promote are obviously "anti-American," unless you consider a higher standard of living for the lower and middle class or higher accountability for the ruling class anti-American. I suppose historically speaking those concepts are anti-American but whether that's a good or bad thing can be left as an exercise to the reader.

Psypeyesterday at 7:02 PM

Nowadays there's a lot of Muslims practicing their faith very differently from what most do. They might drink or smoke, and live a more "flexible" version, their own version of their own faith.

Even if, in fine, you are right despite the downvotes. Islam is also a political and legal system that cannot cohabit with another system (no system can cohabit with another one, you can't have a democracy and a dictature at the same place)

show 2 replies