logoalt Hacker News

ForHackernewsyesterday at 7:22 PM1 replyview on HN

The dream was that you could separate content from presentation and content could be adapted and reinterpreted by anyone using whatever tools they choose: User Agents that actually respected the users' vision, not the publishers'.


Replies

collingreenyesterday at 10:08 PM

And accessibility.

The posts above claiming design and content are inextricably linked are probably blessed with all the standard senses.

As usual it's a bunch of folks talking past each other. Style and content together is a nice simplification when you want to conform to a particular vision. Separation is a nice abstraction if you want to enable multiple views of the same content (like a pdf version or a colorblind version or a vision impaired version) without having to change/control the content.

Like most things in this space, different tradeoffs make one better than the other in different scenarios. Taking a hard stance of "one true way" is probably missing some imagination or experience.

show 2 replies