logoalt Hacker News

boringgtoday at 1:56 PM1 replyview on HN

Not comparable at all. The US is one market unless you have a compelling reason to protect your state market. Canada is 10 separate markets with provincial agreements between them - all protecting themselves. Easiest example is Quebec.

I.e. Opt in vs Opt out but more complicated.


Replies

bryanlarsentoday at 2:19 PM

The US is the opt-in system where the States regulate everything not specifically allocated to the federation and Canada is the opt-out system where the federal government regulates everything not specifically allocated to the provinces.

Of course it's more complicated -- the US's inter-state commerce clause has been broadly interpreted by the courts.