logoalt Hacker News

sobiolitetoday at 2:54 PM3 repliesview on HN

Create an empirically testable theory of biological consciousness and then we can have a meaningful conversation about whether AIs can also have it or not. Until then, this is just so much waffle.


Replies

collingreentoday at 3:10 PM

It's nice when you can set an impossibly high bar before which you can dismiss all your personal responsibility.

Does this argument work equally well for human slavery for you? We haven't met that bar for humans either. Is wondering about my consciousness waffle or do I get a pass in your book?

show 1 reply
krapptoday at 3:10 PM

Why is this only ever demanded of people who criticize the premise that LLMs are conscious beings, whereas the people who believe it simply have to gesture vaguely in the direction of some correlation in language between LLMs and humans, and the matter is considered closed?

What is the empirically tested basis for the null hypothesis that LLMs are conscious until proven otherwise?

show 1 reply