logoalt Hacker News

fshyesterday at 8:02 PM3 repliesview on HN

I would be very surprised if any of the frontier models wasn't trained on all public physics benchmarks. Training data providers have been hiring people for exactly this task.


Replies

letmevotepleaseyesterday at 8:43 PM

This study appears to be evidence against that: the model failed the benchmark but arrived at the correct answer.

show 1 reply
bobmarleybicepsyesterday at 9:09 PM

yeah, it would be almost shocking if an open source benchmark was NOT used ~somewhere in training. Perhaps just pre-training, but still. Neural networks can be fairly robust to some mistakes in their training data, so maybe it doesn't even matter if some of them are incorrect. Who knows.

redwoodtoday at 12:49 AM

I'd have thought the same but this article from yesterday blew my mind https://www.amazon.science/blog/why-dont-machine-learning-re...

As it essential implies that these models compress knowledge well in a way that what remains is what's generalizeable more so than remembering every specific detail... Anyway more understanding necessary but thought provoking