logoalt Hacker News

dmitrygrtoday at 5:07 PM1 replyview on HN

Wait a second...EFF is on the side of: "it is ok to strip out my copyright string from my code"? How did they end up on that side?


Replies

dgellowtoday at 5:11 PM

> Copyright law still protects programmers when their work is unlawfully copied. They can still bring copyright infringement claims if someone uses a model to reproduce their code. Additionally, the plaintiffs’ contract claims against the AI companies are still in play. The specific holding here was narrow but important: that the absence of copyright information from a new work does not mean, by itself, that someone illegally removed it.

I’m not sure I fully understand their argument. If you reproduce the copyrighted work, minus the copyright information, the result is exactly the same as just… removing the copyright information. At least in the case of something digital.

Anyone can help clarify why it is seen as a win? I don't really buy the “small developers will be sued by large corporation for years and forced to settle”

show 2 replies