logoalt Hacker News

eltetotoday at 12:32 PM3 repliesview on HN

While the technology itself may be great (I don't really know since I don't use them) it has been co-opted by the tech conglomerates as another form of isolating and walling off users into their ecosystems.

And honestly, nowadays, if tech companies are pushing really hard for something then that is an immediate red flag for me and it bears more scrutiny. One of those "if you see them running that way you run the opposite way".


Replies

reddalotoday at 1:07 PM

Exactly. That's why I'll never use passkeys: they're just another way to force us into a commercial walled garden.

Passwords with 2FA are simply better and more freedom friendly.

show 1 reply
spider-mariotoday at 12:35 PM

It’s a bit ironic that Apple is the one that lets you export them.

show 1 reply
mschuster91today at 12:42 PM

> And honestly, nowadays, if tech companies are pushing really hard for something then that is an immediate red flag for me and it bears more scrutiny.

The reason is the ever increasing number of hijacks of social media presences and code hosting portals, with the latter being a serious financial threat. Done right, passkeys stay in the Secure Enclave, at least for anything Apple and most of the Android sphere. There is no reasonable way to obtain login credentials for accounts protected by passkeys without physical access to the user's device(s).

show 2 replies