logoalt Hacker News

kshri24today at 1:31 PM1 replyview on HN

> News to me. That would be incredibly xenophobic of them if they did, and deserves to be called out.

What do you mean? Xenophobia does not mean what you think it means, especially so in this context. Also, every creator/producer of content has rights on who/what has access to his/her produced work. It is not xenophobia. And it is definitely not xenophobic to call out stealing of copyrighted works.

EDIT: Let me clarify this further. A recent court ruling (in US) established that ONLY humans can be authors of copyrightable works. As a consequence of that assertion, it can be safely concluded that consumers of the copyrightable work MUST ONLY be humans as well. Else it would be, using your own words, "xenophobic" against humans to have their copyrightable works be consumed by any species (other than humans) while the reverse is not recognized by Law.

https://www.reinhartlaw.com/news-insights/only-humans-can-be...


Replies

TeMPOraLtoday at 1:44 PM

> A recent court ruling (in US) established that ONLY humans can be authors of copyrightable works. As a consequence of that assertion, it can be safely concluded that consumers of the copyrightable work MUST ONLY be humans as well.

That does not follow in any reasonable way.

show 1 reply