logoalt Hacker News

AlexandrBtoday at 3:26 PM1 replyview on HN

Property is a social construct in the sense that anything is a social construct. Like, sure, the fact that I "own" this spoon is societally constructed, but it's so foundational that almost every other aspect of human society is more abstract. Even animals have some sense of "property" - whether that's territory they defend or their stash of food. The social construct part is that we respect each other's property rights (mostly) without resorting violence, where animals resort to individual violence or threat displays.


Replies

qarltoday at 4:15 PM

> anything is a social construct

Well, no, the physical laws aren't social. An apple falls whether there is a social group to see it or not.

And yes! Animals are a perfect example. Mother Nature came up with a nice strategy for maximal benefit in a social group, and she encoded it in our instincts and intuitions.

But that doesn't mean it's perfect. I have an instinctual fear of fire - but it's still better to cook my own food.